terpfan1980 terpfan1980

Theater owners want cell phones blocked

Theater owners want cell phones blocked

Discussed somewhat in this article: A King Kong bomb, or just a very sluggish movie market?, but under serious discussion as noted in the news article below, Theatre owners are apparently getting serious about trying to find ways to end rude behavior by movie patrons who just don't get the message that upon entering a movie theatre their cell phones should be off or at least set in silent ring mode.

I've blogged on the topic before, and Little Whip brought up the problem in comments to the article referenced in the paragraph above, but it is a serious problem, as many cell phone users just never seem to get the message that the world does not revolve around them and the use of their damned phone.

I have to think really hard on whether or not my last trip to a theatre included a ringing cell phone, but I'd swear it did. It's a regular occurence, despite many signs as you enter the multiplex, again as you enter the individual theatre, and even more reminders as the movie started. And yet again, some numbnuts is sitting in the crowd with some stinkin' annoying ring tone that plays some polyphonic symphony as loudly and annonyingly as possible when some friend they forget to fax or e-mail their schedule to doesn't get the agenda for the day and doesn't realize they shouldn't be calling in the middle of the movie.

It wouldn't be a problem at all if some people had better manners, but alas many don't.

When driving on the highway a cell phone should be for emergencies or quick conversations to provide status and note that you'll contact someone later when you aren't driving and shouldn't be concentrating on the roadway around you.

When sitting in a theatre, even if you are expecting a death, birth, or other serious family event, your cell phone should be set to vibrate mode only, or should be turned off.

In either case, if the news is that friggin' important that you couldn't wait just a little longer to receive it, then perhaps you shouldn't be where you are (on the road or in the theatre) and instead should be sitting chained to the damned phone so you can get all your important business completed without interrupting others around you.

Oh, lest I forget, there's a special hell reserved for the idiots that have to sit around you in a restaurant and carry on a cell phone conversation. Most of them are rude on so many levels it's pathetic. First, many of them are sitting at a table with someone else that they are totally ignoring in favor of whomever they are speaking on the phone with, and secondly, many of them are carrying on their phone conversation in such a way as to make the entire surrounding audience a part of their conversation. Either way, it spells "clod" in my book.

And finally, for the people that are so mentally challenged that they can't shop for groceries without walking down the aisles asking someone on the other end of the phone what items to get or not get, shame on them. Learn your significant others eating/drinking habits and shop by knowing what they want, rather than having to ask them all the time. And if the conversation isn't about what you are shopping for, then go back to the aforementioned "use the cell phone just to tell someone you'll talk with them more later" rule and stop trying to drag the rest of the world into your conversation. Never mind the idiots that are standing in the line in front of you at Starbucks ordering a host of drinks with all sorts of special instructions as they try to carry on a conversation via some "hands free" cord. Those folks should already be suffering (hopefully) as they screw their orders up and wind up getting something other than what they asked for. (Though I do feel sorry for the poor baristas who are left waiting for complete instructions or who have to re-make drinks just to get them right when it's the phone user's fault).


In anycase, original news article follows. Now, if you'll pardon me, I'm gonna call up some random cell phone user as they try to watch King Kong. I'm sure it won't take but a few tries to get one to answer while they sit in the movie. :p





Theater owners want cell phones blocked


SANTA MONICA, Calif., Dec. 17 (UPI) -- The National Association of Theater Owners wants the Federal Communications Commission to allow the blocking of cell phone signals in theaters.
John Fithian, the president of the trade organization, told the Los Angeles Times theater owners "have to block rude behavior" as the industry tries to come up with ways to bring people back to the cinemas.
Fithian said his group would petition the FCC for permission to block cell phone signals within movie theaters.
Some theaters already have no cell phone policies and ask moviegoers to check their phones at the door, Fithian said.
The Cellular Telecommunications and Internet Association -- a Washington-based cell phone lobby that is also known as CTIA-the Wireless Association -- said it would fight any move to block cell phone signals.
"We're opposed to the use of any blocking technology, because it interferes with people's ability to use a wireless device in an emergency situation," CTIA spokesman Joseph Farren told the Times.

4,913 views 55 replies
Reply #51 Top
I personally don't agree with cellphone jammers. Other than the fact that it's not legal, it's not right to block everyone else for the misuse of a few. I do like the idea of having an usher inside the theater that will enforce the rules inside theaters. I don't see why an electronic machine is necesary to stop something as simple as stopping people from using their phones inside a theater.

An emergency is just that, an emergency. If anyone has an emergency then they should be leaving the theater, otherwise what would be the point in calling someone inside a theater with an emergency if they will continue to watch the movie. And I'm sorry to say that the birth of a family member (if not ones own child or grandchild) I don't see why it is so important that one has to be informed imediately and has to leave. It's just a baby and chances are they will still be there when you get out (unles something happens and the baby dies, but chances are you might have not gotten there on time as well).

In the end if it is an emergency, there is no reason to stay in the theater talking on the phone. Baker, I am sorry to say that just because you haven't had the bad luck to have a movie ruined by a cell phone doesn't mean it never happens. Consider yourself lucky and I hope you don't have to have your next 2 months ruined by these phones so you can then come here and write an article about how annoying they are in theaters.

So no to jamming machines, yes to ushers inside the movie theater rooms, yes to enforcing the rules, yes to if you don't like it, leave.
Reply #52 Top
In 1995 I lived in Texas.

I have an FCC license from my radio station days and they are good for life unless lost for misuse. I lived next to a single female who had various scum bags move in and out of her house.

One such scumbag called "Rooster" brought a huge antenna with him and strapped it to the side of her house. He was a "ham" operator. (Powerful cb radios basically).

Whenever Rooster keyed up his mic it came across every electrical appliance with a speaker in my home. The tv, radio, house sound system, EVERYTHING.

He was a vulgar mouthed man and used the f-word every other second. He talked about repulsive sex acts for hours on end. My kid would be watching Barney on video and all the sudden Rooster was screeching his profanity and senselessness right over top.

When I got my FCC license I had to read a thing talking about profanity yadda yadda yadda. So I figured if I couldn't cuss over the air ways then ol Rooster was certainly breaking some FCC law.

Nope.

I called them and they said tuff titty sister! Get some "filtering" equipment. The "private" sector air ways are just that, private, and we can't control them one way or another...UNLESS I tried blocking his signal and he reported ME then I'd be in big trouble (though they didn't elaborate I got the picture that such equipment would block him, no big deal to them, but also other airways that they ARE responsible for regulating, which is a crime)...But, He can say and do whatever he likes with his air time. There are no restrictions.

I was deliberating on doing just that anyway when HIS WIFE showed up at my door asking if a man with a "rooster" horn on his truck was staying anywhere around. Pfft. I told her he was shacking up next door. He was gone within two days, his antenna with him. Adiós!

Ok, sorry to get off there.

While a home owner may get away with blocking equipment I don't think theaters will. The FCC is really outdated and has not kept up with technology. IMO they are just basically glorified ticket writers/finers.
I can understand actual equipment blocking signals being illegal...however, it movie theaters BUILT themselves, or remodeled with MATERIAL that just happens to block signals, no one could gain say them.
Reply #53 Top
Chip, the reality is they do exist: Link
It is not rocket science.


Didn't say it rocket science. It is radio wave propagation theory, though, and that has been known to be over many people's heads. Mine included until I was forced to learn it from a Marine that would kick me in the head when I got answers wrong.

That device is pretty much what I described. A transmitter that hits the part of the EM spectrum used by cell phones. The problem that these devices can cause is signal bleed if not tuned exactly to the ranges needed. That would be the requirement - affect only cell phones (pagers, too, I'd assume) within the theater auditoreum only.

This example is from Mexico where the FCC has no say. The FCC regulates things like this. Devices would have to work in exact bands and freq ranges and designated zones. No bleed over. They would also only be able to work within the confines of the designated area. 100 foot radius means that if placed next to an exit, they are jamming 90 feet away from the theater.

Who will monitor these systems to make sure they are in compliance? A highly paid techknowitall? Or the usher on duty between showings of Harry Potter? That guy can't even rip a ticket stub properly...
Reply #54 Top
Realistically Gid, how frequently do you think doctors, emergency personnel, or even Zoomba's hypothetical on-call 24x7 IT workers (something I too am familar with) are really getting out to movie houses to see the current crop of block buster films?


Actually Terpfan, it happens all the time (especially in areas with all volunteer fire and ambulance services). We went to movies, class, church, and other places while on call also. We were radio dispatched (not cell phone), but most volunteer services have dropped the on call walkie talkies lately since most volunteers have cell phones now.

The point is (as usual) the phone itself isn't the problem, the idiot with the phone is.
Reply #55 Top
The point is (as usual) the phone itself isn't the problem, the idiot with the phone is.


I think that pretty much says it. If I were them, I'd just build a building with terrible reception. That'd take care of the problem.

Dan