Creation vs. Evolution
To quote Phoebe from Friends: "I guess the real question is who put those fossils there and why?"
, gah.
Sure, the JW sect is a cult....but little more than any other stylized religion.
I recall the dummy-spitting over RCs and contraception.....just as 'bad'.
The difference, however with JW is that the adult's decision regarding transfusions 'CAN' kill their child 'un-necessarily' [quaint, that], and 'should' be classified as criminal negligence at least, and murder at best.
But then every cult has its foibles....cool-aide, etc....that 'attract' the disparate and desperate or like-minded followers, ultimately making THEIR Religion superior to others through personal selection [or up-bringing], nothing more.
More often than not, it ends up as the blue-eyes Vs the brown-eyes...or the whites Vs the blacks...or the Catholics Vs the Protestants...or the Fascists Vs the Jews [and everyone else]...ad nauseum.
Any group, faction, religion or cult, call it what you will, that ostracises, punishes or actually hurts or allows hurt of ANY individual in its teachings/doctrine is JUST PLAIN WRONG and has lost its direction AND relevance.
I'd rather be a member of HUMANITY than any of the Religious cults out there....and I mean EVERY SINGLE ONE of them...
| why? What do you see that I do not? Then I would like to ask, why should I care? You have your religious beliefs and I will not single you out and vilify you for them, don't presume to do that to me for not accepting yours as my own truths and reality. Thats the point, stop preaching. |
| if saying the word penis will actually send ppl to hell then we're all in big trouble, I can however think of lots of other words that might qualify me though... and me will try to stay out of this thread, before I get into trouble *sigh* |
| No offense but it has always been clear to me that the pressure is on you to follow the beliefs of JW. So if that is your only option to get a blood transfusion because other methods have been tried and failed or shown to not work in a particular case of the patient what do you do? |
| Is it really a choice? Loose the family of people you love and care for in your church? To feel shunned? |
| I do not pretend to think that other religions do not have such 'rules' as to how to make a choice but even my friends do not have an answer for that. One in particular does not care what people think about her so her choice was easy. |
| As I have written before, the Bible seems to be interpreted in many different fashions. If you can not admit that others can not be just as passionate about how it 'should' be done and how (much like you) feel that they are right then there really isn't much to debate. |
| How exactly is there to be spiritual growth without opposing opinions? |
| I do not say there is any true religion but those who allow individual thought and growth without 'nagging points' or 'mental games' are usually the best. |
| It isn't a personal choice if you are punished for it. |
| If a JW takes a blood transfusion they lose their peers and possibly family. |
| When someone is shunned by the Jehovah's Witnesses, the remaining JWs are *compelled* not to have contact, even with family. If they do, they can be shunned as well. This isn't an easy choice either when you are brainwashed. |
| This is administration by isolation and fear. It is a classic example of cultish control; the main symptom of it, actually. Separate people, indoctrinate them, and then they must obey unquestioningly or face expulsion and loss of their friends and family. Shameful and sick. It prevents cultish religions from having light shed on their cultishness. |
| You said: "Thats not even a teaching of ours, the punishing in afterlife. " That's funny, too. You can't be a part of the Kingdom of God if you aren't a Jehovah's Witness, and if you do anything that goes against the teachings, you are shunned... meaning you are no longer a Jehovah's Witness. If that isn't punishment in the afterlife, what is? , gah. |
| You have to understand that Genesis was written by people without knowlegde of the "theory" of evolution. So he is going to explain creation in terms that could be comprehended by him and the people around him. The human race and the rest of the world was not made in seven days. The theory of evolution is pretty much concrete but not all scientists have accepted it as cold, hard fact. |
| The difference, however with JW is that the adult's decision regarding transfusions 'CAN' kill their child 'un-necessarily' [quaint, that], and 'should' be classified as criminal negligence at least, and murder at best. |
| But then every cult has its foibles....cool-aide, etc....that 'attract' the disparate and desperate or like-minded followers, ultimately making THEIR Religion superior to others through personal selection [or up-bringing], nothing more. |
| More often than not, it ends up as the blue-eyes Vs the brown-eyes...or the whites Vs the blacks...or the Catholics Vs the Protestants...or the Fascists Vs the Jews [and everyone else]...ad nauseum. |
| Any group, faction, religion or cult, call it what you will, that ostracises, punishes or actually hurts or allows hurt of ANY individual in its teachings/doctrine is JUST PLAIN WRONG and has lost its direction AND relevance. |
| I'd rather be a member of HUMANITY than any of the Religious cults out there....and I mean EVERY SINGLE ONE of them... |
| sooooo everyone agrees that creation is the only way it all happened? Good. It's settled. |
| Soooooo, what happens if we are wrong? And this "The Earth is round" stuff just doesn't fly with me. How many years under the church suppossedly backed by the Bible, was the Earth said to be flat? Thousands of years of that can't be wrong. So, its creation and a flat Earth. Agreed? Good. |
. Lies? um, yeah.I'm still stuck on the concept/circumstance that can empower a 'religion' to legitimize reckless endangerment for the sake of dubious interpretation of an old book...a fictional tabloid of indeterminate origin.
What 'right' is inherent in an individual to determine proper care of another in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary?
A doctor doing such would face malpractise [at least].
Joe-Public would face criminal negligence [or worse].
A JW gets away with it because 'someone' had a poor understanding of written comprehension [or just swooned at the sight of blood] and factored it into his/their religious 'factionism'.
Too too bad if you are a haemophiliac.....and your mum bows and scrapes before Jehovah......
This has to be a serious turn-off in the JW recruitment success-rate....a cult based on Russian Roulette would be just as clever.
Call this a counter to the pro-JW propaganda, but without the interminable scripture-quoting [I, too, have read it already], and is a check and balance [right of reply] to demonstrate just one teensy-weensy glitch in the appeal of this 'flavour' of Religion.
Stupidity knows many forms....
| That pretty much takes the grand prize for nutty, nonsensical statements I have seen here. Kona will have a hard time beating that one... |
| SO with the being cast out of the community and your family, and the being destroyed for eternity part, there's no negative reinforcement for these "personal choices"? Jehovah's Witnesses have no reason to make harmful decisions when they are bleeding to death, or their children are molested? . Lies? um, yeah. |
| Do you think it is easy to keep that many people that much in line, all singing the same little tune? You think people are naturally that homogeneous? Hell no, it takes cultish control to keep that kind of uniformity. |
| The odd thing about that website ( Link ) is that it is filled with information provided by EX-Jehovah's Witnesses. So I really don't have to "attend a few meetings", I can get the accounts of all the people that have. If that site is 'full of lies' why not have it shut down? The JW leadership has plenty of legal resources and oodles of money. |
| Please stop this pasting of scripture and doctrine provided to you by the Watchtower folks. We are posting our own thoughts here, not just vomiting doctrine. Your literalist sermons only prove the Atheistic point-of-view, giving them more and more examples of how destructive and illogical 'religion' can be. Feel free to talk about Evolution, but I am sick of you using it as a platform for Watchtower propaganda. |
| A JW gets away with it because 'someone' had a poor understanding of written comprehension [or just swooned at the sight of blood] and factored it into his/their religious 'factionism'. |
| This has to be a serious turn-off in the JW recruitment success-rate....a cult based on Russian Roulette would be just as clever. |
| and if you think there is no Hell well that sounds pretty comfortable but I hope you're right cuz I personally hate heat... |
| JW is a cult. I can tell just by what you said here and reading the links you gave. POINT BEING: I do not wish someone forcing scipture down my throat when I come to WC. So knock if off OK? |
| BTW: if you want to get out of that religion I know some pretty good Christian outreach programs for JW/mormons. You might want to take a look at your religion and question your beliefs. After all, blind faith can be deceiving. |
| And there is a Hell and a enternity of punishment awaiting evildoers. Only God can say who is going to be cast to there. You can NOT have God without having Satan. You must have the evil to have the good. |
| Actually I have a good defense. In the Bible (if you read it and believe it) It does say over and over that there is a hell. And it does say that the evildoers will burn in a flame that will last for eternity. |
Oh, I think it's about overdue that this thread got back on topic.
Everyone has been guilty of digression, but it's 'supposed' to be about Evolution vs Creation.
There is exactly NO relevance between this and a recruitment drive/promotion of the Jehovah's Witnesses, or for that matter the debunking thereof.
I think that absolutely nothing is gained from the re-iteration and regurgitation of entire tracts of a book in offense/defense of one specific version of religion.
Converts will not be had nor souls lost to eternal damnation by a website thread content, no matter what people may think/hope....
| Hell is a place of inactivity |
| #1018 by PowerUser joetheblow - 11/5/2003 4:58:07 PM | ||||||
SO? The Church and those who supposedly read the Bible and all of those in authority said it did. Now when all those who teach you the Bible and what it means says something it usually holds weight. This is an instance (ANOTHER ONE) where THE SAME SOURCE IS USED TO DESCRIBE SOMETHING. Can't admit that 'they' or 'we' or 'you' can use a source and make it to prove a point that you believe in??? It is your belief that that is what it MEANS. The Bible will always say something, BUT it is up to us to interpret that saying into MEANING THAT is where humanity goes wrong. Its a little harder to say the same of science because it leaves itself open for scrutiny. Unlike religion where it is believed by a GROUP that this is what the source means. Now that does not mean science can't be wrong, but science isn't exactly saying its 100% correct (99.999949959% is not 100% correct) Science has some idea that evolution must have taken place but there are some holes in the theory. For me, I believe evolution is a possibility and could have or is happening. Do I have faith in it??? NO. Do I think creation is how it happened. Yes. do I have faith in it? Yes. Can I say there is a possibility that it didn't happen that way? Yes. Does me being open to the idea that it might now be creation but evolution mean my faith IS SHATTERED TO PIECES as far as creation is concerned? No. Some will have you believe the world is black and white with some grays when it is actually full of colors. Literally. So jokingly I say this: The Universe was created and the Earth is flat. ------------------------------------- Some words to look up on individual perception, group think and other human, social, organizational attributes: Attribution Theory Halo Effect reading Comprehension Comprehension Perceived/Settings/perception Group development Group Think. Organizational Behavior Some of which is on my blog and on my JTB-development blog site at joeuser.com =================================================
|
|
joetheblow...
I had to delete your post....it'd fragged the thread page badly.
I posted what I could of it again for you...
| Maybe you didn't realize the first 4 words you stated earlier...Hell is a place Are you contradicting yourself? |
| SO? The Church and those who supposedly read the Bible and all of those in authority said it did. |
| Can't admit that 'they' or 'we' or 'you' can use a source and make it to prove a point that you believe in??? |
| It is your belief that that is what it MEANS. The Bible will always say something, BUT it is up to us to interpret that saying into MEANING THAT is where humanity goes wrong. |
| Yes, if you accept blood there will be consequences, but you'll not be aware of these if you're dead. |
| I think Moses got it right when he wrote it. That someone elses blood isn't to be in anothers body. |
| The consequences are perfectly clear. If that is enforced upon a child by the parents then these parents should be charged with murder. Because that is what it is. |
| Nah. I spoke to Moses on the phone the other day and he said: "I am so sorry, MadIce. I made a booboo. I never thought medical science would advance in such a way these days. But I have found the answer to save those poor JWs. We offer blood from lugworms soon. Maybe those nasty JWs can be saved afterall. We provided that to stop them from manslaughter in the future. Clever, hey?." |
| I know it is off topic but I wanted to add that the JW have rewritten the bible just like the mormons have. |
Welcome Guest! Please take the time to register with us.