Twilight gets 9.0 and Editor's Choice @ GameSpot
http://www.gamespot.com/pc/strategy/galacticcivilizationsiitwilightofthearnor/review.html?om_act=convert&om_clk=multimodule&tag=multimodule;picks;title;1
from 
GalCiv2 Forums
GalCiv2 Forums
I'm not entirly sure where to put this, so I decided to post it here.
"Adding this much new life to what should be a very familiar game is an amazing achievement. While no single addition here can be said to make this expansion, the scope of the subtle yet wide-ranging changes greatly improve the Galactic Civilizations II experience. Before Twilight of the Arnor, players could stick to the Terrans and encounter everything that the game had to offer. Now, you deal with something new each and every time you go galaxy conquering with a different alien race, which freshens up a game that was in need of exactly this kind of facelift."
The review is very much postive.
"Adding this much new life to what should be a very familiar game is an amazing achievement. While no single addition here can be said to make this expansion, the scope of the subtle yet wide-ranging changes greatly improve the Galactic Civilizations II experience. Before Twilight of the Arnor, players could stick to the Terrans and encounter everything that the game had to offer. Now, you deal with something new each and every time you go galaxy conquering with a different alien race, which freshens up a game that was in need of exactly this kind of facelift."
The review is very much postive.