Why do we have to call them African Americans?

My friend's article Link made me wonder this yet again: Why did we used to call them (please forgive me) Niggers, then Negroes, then Blacks, and now African Americans?

I remember a friend in high school who was unmistakably dark-skinned, the darkest a person can possibly be. She was a friend, and of course I didn't think anything of her race because we were simply friends. So one day in casual conversation she said that none of her ancestors are from Africa. She said that she is completely Jamaican. That's interesting. Fine, I thought. I wondered if at some point her Jamaican ancestors hadn't come from Africa, but I know virtually nothing about migration, so I didn't think about it for too long.

My point is, is "African American" a fair label for our dark-skinned friends? Maybe they're not all from Africa. Then what should we call them? I personally was fine with "black," and I even thought that "negro" was a perfectly acceptable categorization until my aunt went raving mad at me for describing to her 4-year-old daughter that the girl in the pink dress on the Chutes-n-Ladders game was a negro. My aunt heard me from another room, and she lost it, then right away she had a long talk with her daughter to re-indoctrinate her to the politically correct way to refer to the darker race: "African American."

Sheesh.

By the way, black people call each other black (and worse things). But goodness forbid if a white person uses any such taboo word. That would be racist, right? Why does our society still walk on eggshells about this?

2,011 views 13 replies
Reply #1 Top
because if you do not you will be BRANDED racist, OR uncaring, OR out of touch, Or any other name some politically correct JERK can come up with.
Reply #2 Top
"My point is, is "African American" a fair label for our dark-skinned friends? Maybe they're not all from Africa. Then what should we call them?"
I find this to be a bit strange. Maybe I'm just messed in the head but who do you know who calls black people African-Americans whether they are or not? I don't think that's the reality these days. Maybe it is and I'm out the loop when it comes to today's language translation. African American refers to black people who have roots going back to Africa. Blacks from Jamaica are, to me, Jamaican-Americans. Do people say differently?
Reply #3 Top
OK Moderateman, but what if some people claim no African heritage? Then what are they? Can't we just call them "American?" Or what about this family I know who are British, but unmistakably dark-skinned? African-European?

What a mouthful.

I am about 6 different races, and I will never insist on anyone referring to me by all of them.
Reply #5 Top
Thanks Iconoclast. That's a great article, and it produced great comments. It's funny: I think I'm all alone in this little brain of mine, then nice people like you point me toward others who're thinking the same things I am, but in a more intellectual way.
Reply #6 Top
#3 by AngelaMarie88
Wednesday, June 15, 2005


OK Moderateman, but what if some people claim no African heritage? Then what are they? Can't we just call them "American?" Or what about this family I know who are British, but unmistakably dark-skinned? African-European?


I know hon, it's ridiculous, I could DEMAND to be called a turkish american since I am first generation american from 2 Turkish parents, but then how do I get across I am jewish also, Political correctness is destroying america and I am sick of it.
Reply #7 Top
others who're


Others whore? lol
Political correctness is destroying america and I am sick of it.


Political Correctness gets in the way of the truth.
Reply #8 Top
Others whore? lol


haha
Reply #9 Top
For the record, y'all can refer to me as an Irish-German-Spaniard-Navajo-Mexican-American from now on. If you call me a Mutt I will be severely offended and I will think of you as a racist.

Ha!

I jest.
Reply #10 Top
Political Correctness gets in the way of the truth.


good words icon, truth....
Reply #11 Top
Angela, what I have found is that short of the big "N" word, the only people who care what word you happen to use are those who are seeking out offense, even when no offense was meant. At worst the rest will think your a bit behind the times, at best they will shrug it off, or tell you which term they personally prefer.

Course, I could be wrong, but I think my day to be wrong this week was yesterday. ;~D
Reply #12 Top
Call them whatever the hell you want to. Who says you need to conform to the latest PC-buzzword?

For instance, I call them: "people".

-- B
Reply #13 Top

Great Article.  Another misnomer is the term Hispanic.  It is applied to all people from south of the border. Yet one of the largest nations in the world, and the largest south of us is not Spanish at all.  It is Portuguese,and they have little if any in common with the rest of central and south America.  Yet they are still called Hispanic.

And some of the bluest eyed blond haired people are also called Hispanic.  Why?  They are actually from Spain!