Phoon Phoon

Serious Ratings Abuse Still Happening

▼

Serious Ratings Abuse Still Happening

rehashing an old favorite

from WinCustomize Forums
I can't help but notice that as of late, there has been some serious rating slamming happening particularly in the Windowblinds section.
There have been some fine themes that are getting hammered with 1 and 2 stars and some mediocre themes getting 3 and 4.
When Boxxi puts out a new one like Gold Carbon and its getting rated at 2 stars, I think that is proof enough.
It seems we have hashed and rehashed this issue, yet nothing ever gets done about it.
Why can't we have the following rules for ratings, it WOULD do a great deal to solve the issue.
#1) If you are going to rate, you MUST leave a comment.
#2) Your username, comment and rating are visible to the skinner at least.
27,387 views 103 replies
Reply #26 from WinCustomize Forums Top
I think what would be nice is to have the rating buttons disabled by default, then have them "activated" when the download button has been clicked.
Reply #27 from WinCustomize Forums Top
::nods:: I most definitely agree with you there sleeping Dragon..I apologize for not completely understanding what you meant.

Zero.
Ashes of the Singularity II
Reply #28 from WinCustomize Forums Top
I may be wrong but isnt there a certain rank if you rate alot of skins .I was looking at stats in users homepages and there is an amount of rates then in parenthesis it has rank. Do some people think the more things they rate they'll become #1 raters?lol Enlighten me if I'm wrong
Reply #29 from WinCustomize Forums Top
no prob 00. I think there is a person or two that is attempting to become king o' the rates, gooberbean28.
Reply #30 from WinCustomize Forums Top
As a reflection,

The preview of a skin does reveal quite a bit about it, and definitely sways my decision either way about whether or not to indeed download it..But,,unless you actually download it and use it, the fact remains..there is no one you can ultimatley give it any type of fair rating.

Zero.
Reply #31 from WinCustomize Forums Top
lol, SD guess some people want to be numero uno of everything, but it is a serious problem because of this rating fiasco some good skinners have left WC and others are just plain tired of it, Which is a shame because of this there's alot of good skins we'll never see
Reply #32 from WinCustomize Forums Top
I think (and nobody asked for my opinion) that it is in this site's best interest to do away with the ratings altogether.
Reply #33 from WinCustomize Forums Top
Or double zeros idea a dual rating an average citizen rating to see how the average joe likes it and another rating by journeyman and higher that are more knowledgable about skin making???? And if its a 4 or higher by your superiors or a 1 or 2 by average joe the superiors ratings take precedent over the average citizens?? Just a thought.
Reply #34 from WinCustomize Forums Top
Dont the ratings serve as perhaps an added incentive for some artisits to keep creating? The comments are great way for people to interact with that artisit, a pat on the back, good job..etc..etc.. but we all know that most of the time people tend to DL and there gone, no comment, no thank you..zilch. Some of the skins all the artists have to go by is the rating they have recieved due to that very thing. I am sure some of the newer artists definitely aspire to have their work rated highly, perhaps as high as some of their own favorite artists that have inspired them to give skinning a shot..

I think the rating system is a decent incentive to some so I disagree with removing it altogether.But I do agree with the fact that it has to perhaps be restructured and There should be a set of criteria for ratings.

Zero.
Reply #35 from WinCustomize Forums Top
yeah, you're right, Zero. It just seems that they are (and maybe always have been) the cause of quite a bit of dissension.
Reply #36 from WinCustomize Forums Top
Zero sometimes the ratings also cause good skinners to disappear from WC too I like your dual rating idea!
Reply #37 from WinCustomize Forums Top
Old Crab is going back to his old system.
This thread is - Crab Rated: 9.44
Reply #38 from WinCustomize Forums Top
Ty Gooberbean, it was just a thought I threw out there after I read the 1st post of Filko?? (Im sorry if I got that SN wrong)in the thread he began.. There has got to be other alternatives and answers other than quiting.. I was just hoping to get people to start looking more to the positive..You guys know what the problems are..ya gotta focus more on the solutions..
And it didnt look like thats where it was going..LoL..

Zero.
Reply #39 from WinCustomize Forums Top
And yes gooberbean, some do it only for the ratings dispite what you may think....tons of screenshots, ports, meaningless comments and ratings on every skin they can find, just to get a high count in skin comments and skin ratings and downloads..., you seem to be blind to that fact concerning some of your friends, but it is the truth ..
Reply #40 from WinCustomize Forums Top
Boss I know people do it just for the ratings. Friends? everybody is my friend , you are a friend.I try to get along with everybody.Why jump on me, I have no control over other people, have I ever done it? No. Have I done something to you that you seem to not like me?
Reply #41 from WinCustomize Forums Top
Sheesh, I hope he isnt refering to me..I cant even have a rating yet ..im just here because I am bored and dont have anyone else to play with..LoL..


Zero.
Reply #42 from WinCustomize Forums Top
Bean, I was just kind of responding to your comment in #28 that some people KNOW that the more they rate they will become #1..of course I have nothing against you, I just know, or think I do, that you communicate a fair amount with the #1 abuser of the ratings system..In My Opinion..and was enlightening you to my feelings on the matter
Reply #43 from WinCustomize Forums Top
I understand what your saying Boss, I'm just trying to help figure a way some of this ratings abuse can be straightened out , these skinners take alot of time and expect some reasonable feedback on the art they design.I cant control what others do on their comps,lol
Reply #44 from WinCustomize Forums Top
I have to agree with Phoon's rules in the original statement to open thread.

If I am not mistaken, the ratings are also used to specify which art is displayed to general public users who do not have an account.

I believe that only 3-1/2 stars (7) or above are viewable without logging in. Unless this portion of the ratings use is changed, it might be a lot of work for the Administrators and Moderators to identify which art is to be displayed to the general public and which is not.

In light of this, I believe Phoon's idea to be the best alternative and fairly realistic to implement without creating a huge addition to the work load already facing the staff.

Just my 2 cents.
Reply #45 from WinCustomize Forums Top
Ratings help with searching, and there are plenty of people who really do appreciate the ratings, so getting rid of it seems much less than neccesary. How much abuse are people REALLY sure is happening anyway? Just because something has a low rating means abuse? Lets tell Jafo straight-a-way so he can put that evil-doer in his place? As if they're not entitled to make such opinions. Some stuff deserves a low rating, and basically everyone that can evaluate the skin has the right to rate it whatever the hell they want.

People only start to whine/complain/bicker/feel wronged or whatever level of disagreement ensues, when they get a low rating. OMG a 2 rating, foul play...FOUL PLAY!!! SYSTEM ABUSE!!!!111oneone. My best advice is to GET OVER IT, the only way to make these people happy is to change the system from 1-10 to 7-10. A low rating doesn't instantly or even probably by the majority, mean abuse.

Not that abuse isn't out there, but how much of it's low rates? Do you not think as much as someone might rate something low for the wrong reasons i.e. "i dont like this person". How much do you think people rate their friends high for no other reason than they ARE their friends or they're "important". And why do people keep thinking that just because a particular person uploads a skin, that he/she automatically deserves a high rating just because of who they are?

No one deserves a high rating because of what name they have, or title they use, or whatever else they've done, or any of that crap. The skin is getting rated not the person. Do people really find it THAT neccesary to suck up? Oh look at particular person just uploaded a skin, he's a admin/higher up/important for some reason/friend/big community member/popular in general, lets rate him high and leave a "you r0x0rz dude" comment.

Besides, a rating of one person is important, but these work on an average, so the most logical complaint is more people should rate, if 30 people rate and it gets a 4, what can you say? All 30 people are heartless rating system abusing meanies? And why should anyone other than admins have knowledge of who rated them what? If I voted for Bush and the state of indiana whines about it should they be able to exclude my vote, or deem it wrong, or know who the hell I voted for at all? Would we need to backup every vote with a 2 paragraph comment like, well Bush did this or that, and Kerry didn't so I'm going this way, plus the whole tax thing, and Kerry looks too much like Jay Leno. Screw that, your vote counts whether you tell the rest of the world why or not, and they know you voted FOR a reason. Whether it's just "my" opinion or not doesn't matter, rating is opinion based, not fact based. And nothing like "but he put so much work into it" matters much either. You can spend your entire life making crap, and 2 hours making a masterpiece. But people have the right to describe in whatever way they feel to be true, some people like crap.

Boss019 rates Boxxi low(ish) should he worry about giving his honest opinion just because Boxxi is an admin? Should he feel like he's done something wrong? Can you prove he's wrong? Should his rating on the skin be reset just because he didn't say "boxxi is the man and i rated you a 10!!". Should anyone feel insulted when getting a low rating? Or should they take REAL feedback in a positive way? If it gets a 10 awesome. If it gets a 3, maybe you should figure out WHY AND FIX IT. You can always improve on it, whats the point of whining about it and getting the rating boosted just to make someone feel better?
One might also take note that his rating has already changed from a 4 to a 5, what that means is able to be interpreted many a ways, maybe he'll end up with a 9 on that one, maybe not. Maybe it's just the people rating have a different taste. Ratings is just one type of feedback of basically 3, each work different, and for what it's worth, probably SHOULD.

And being forced to leave a comment? What good will that do? It just highlights someone to be open for being a target. The people that rate good don't do any different when they rate poorly. Like someone giving something a 3 rating needs to give more opinion than "I don't like it, or I don't think it works well." The people that rate high don't do anything better! They just give a high rating, and if they say anything at all, it's typically, "nice, i like it, and all your work." Well geez how can one argue with that, "nice, i like it" sure says a lot, and definetly backs up that 10 rating you just handed out eh? No one complains about giving high ratings and not commenting.

ANYWAYS, this all comes down to one thing, people think they themselves or other certain people ALWAYS deserve a high rating, it just isn't that way, so stop whining, stop crying wolf, stop assuming because someone didn't give a high rating to someone you deserve to know who they are, or that they're an abuser, stop acting like low ratings are the only kind of abuse, and stop acting like you can stop the abuse, or that ratings are the only thing that GET abused. And uhhh if you are thinking I'm calling out anyone specific, stop that too please I don't need to come back later and see "shut your mouth horiz0n I'm not like that" cause I didn't say you were

On something I think is important in my eyes, essencay wins todays lottery imo. When a normal user submits a skin, if I'm the first to rate it, and I give it a 1 it goes to like a 4, if I rate it a 10, it's going to be around an 8 or so. When a journyman submits and I'm the first to rate, if I give it a 1, it goes to 1, if I give him/her a 10, they get an instant 10. Thats the only thing I see worth changing.
Reply #46 from WinCustomize Forums Top

My personal opinion, stated many times over the last few years, is that rating should be made public, ideally linked to comments and downloads. That way someone would have to download a skin and comment to rate it.

There's nothing wrong with giving a low rating to something you don't like - just say why! Same for a high rating.

Drive-by raters will not be given any sympathy and will be dealt with accordingly.

Finally, like most people here, I'm getting sick of hearing about ratings. I just wish the moaning minnies would find something else to whinge about. There's hardly a week goes by without an outburst - enough already, shut-up and skin something.

Reply #47 from WinCustomize Forums Top
So this is trhread number 1.274.658.564 or something like that about ratings. And nothing changes and I guess will never change. So IMHO the solution is to leave it all like it is and pay no attention to whatever rating is given. Comments ditto unless something constructive is left. Sure, it's nice to have comments like "great, nice" and so on , better then "crap" but it doesn't anything at all what makes me benefit.
Reply #48 from WinCustomize Forums Top
There's nothing wrong with giving a low rating to something you don't like - just say why! Same for a high rating.


Just out of curiosity, would a "because I don't like it" satisfy you as a comment? There's nothing more idiotic than expecting someone to explain their personal taste. I have no qualms about leaving detailed negative comments, should it be required of me, but I have no desire to be exiled because I'm forced to explain why I abhor a skin and then be punished for it, because someone's feelings were hurt in the process.
Reply #49 from WinCustomize Forums Top

The ratings are intended to be a 'filter' to select generally agreed 'better' works for public viewing/download. The intent is that actual registered users can contribute to this 'filter' with their opinion of the 'appropriately tested' work by applying a rating.  Currently, the higher up the 'social ladder' [via experience - input - dedication - promotion] the more weight is granted to your opinion/rating...which effectively counter-balances the 'novice' without much experence of the craft.

99% of the time the ratings look quite 'right'.  Every now and then there is an anomaly...which sets bells ringing....and is dealt with....privately.

It's important to re-iterate that all the ratings are visible and time-lined.  They are NOT anonymous...not to those vested with the responsibility of maintaining decorum.

Now and then...heads roll.  It gets resolved.....

If I only had a dollar for each thread posted about ratings.....I'd buy an Island...not a little island....

Reply #50 from WinCustomize Forums Top
I understand the frequency of threads like this, and I didn't mean to poke a stick in the hornets nest again either.
Perhaps the frequency indicates that people are a tad disturbed by the system and it deserves to be thought out again by the powers that be.
I see quite a few skins with great comments and low ratings. That indicates a problem. period.
On the other side of the coin, the admins to a good job of policing the abuse if it is drawn to their attention. It just seems like the whistle needs blown more now. Here's one last thought then I walk away from the swarm I made..
Could be that people are rating using the old 1-10 system on the current 1-5 scale. That could explain the surge.