WinCustomize Policy on Copyright

Each website no the Internet has to wrestle with the issue of copyright. This is our policy.

Fair Use
Skins, themes, icons may use content created by others for the purposes of making what is popularly considered "fan art". So if you want to make a Star Wars based wallpaper or Superman skin you may do so.  We reserve the right to remove it in the event that the owner of the trademarked or copyrighted material objects (for instance, Marvel objecting to non-licensed use of Marvel characters) but in general we will accept skins, themes, icons, and wallpapers that are fan art as long as the user uploading them created it. Taking someone else's Batman wallpaper and uploading it is not going to be accepted. Creating your own Batman wallapper would be accepted.

Ports
Porting skins and themes created by others for a different platform or program is acceptable. Ports are often a great way for new skinners to learn how to skin.  My first skins were ports.  However, you must get permission to port the skin/theme from the original author in order to distribute it.  Porting of operating systems is generally accepted and would fall under the "fan art" rules. 

As a general philosophy, skins and themes that highlight and promote favorably an existing thing that is already known to people is acceptable. That is why we accept fan art but why it's not okay to take an individual's skins and port them without permission.

4,614 views 14 replies
Reply #1 Top
My logon "Ogre Battle" was turned down twice however I have seen at least a half a dozen just on the first 5 or 6 pages that were no different than mine, IE "McGee's Alice". I don't see why mine was turned down while this was accepted. Could you please explain it to me. Keep in mind the second time I submitted this logon I completely removed anything that mentioned the game. All that remained was the charactures on a black background.
Reply #2 Top

Copyrights not withstanding, Logons, Bootskins and Wallpapers in particular are moderated for 'quality' as well.

For example, too often a Logon is nothing more than a single wall image inserted and nothing else.  That isn't 'skinning' .... that is 'background replacement'.

Walls are a priority target for 'moderation' as without same there would be an insurmountable flood of exceedingly average images purporting to be wallpapers.....

Reply #3 Top
I'm sorry to differ with you but alot of work went into that logon especially the second submitance. I did not simply "replace the background", I redid the entire thing so as not to violate any rules. I dont know if you have seen it or not but your making assumptions.
Reply #4 Top

No...I'm not making 'assumptions', I am making generalisations.

There's a difference.

This thread is not for specific instances to be debated.  Emailing a moderator is the desired approach....however I've checked that specific one for you and it's up now....


[Message Edited]
Reply #5 Top
Thanks. Didn't mean to get into a debate. Sorry.
Reply #6 Top
I think this is a great way to go. Thanks.
Reply #7 Top
#1
Porting of operating systems is generally accepted and would fall under the "fan art" rules.

Huh? What does this mean?
Reply #8 Top
Using images inherent to the Windows OS to develop skins for the Windows OS....
Reply #9 Top
or might be making some sort of MACY Skins
Reply #10 Top
I started looking at bootskins today and after looking at quite a few, I started noticing some of questionable copyright or they may just be FanArt...I'm really not sure. Well eventually I went through the entire library and came up with a list of 50 or so bootskins. If any admin would like a copy of the list (with links), I'll be happy to email it to him. As I said they may just be FanArt and I am being over zealous
Reply #12 Top
either that or a dirty snitch


or maybe I have respect for the artists that create original content who have to post their stuff along side the cut-n-paste screenshots from games and images from other sites type of crap that some people post here.
Reply #13 Top
I just think you guys went to far when you turn down a screenshot because the wallpaper is not covered enough... This is probably the only skinning site where I have seen that happened. In other words someone that uses minimal styled desktops will never be able to post one here...
Reply #14 Top

Diafragma....yes they can....provided one of two things happens...

1.  it is your own wall image [and you say so].

or

2. You get consent to distribute from its owner....just like any other copyright situation.

Yep, this stance may be uncommon and you get away with it on other sites but so too can you get pirated skins on other sites....same copyright issue...