Feedback Please

This is my first logon theme. I would appreciate some comments (made in the logon's comment box, not here) letting me know what I did well, what I screwed up, and how I can do logons better in the future.

https://www.wincustomize.com/skins.asp?library=26&SkinID=589
2,110 views 8 replies
Reply #1 Top
please?
Reply #2 Top
I just started logons too. Just watch your downloads compared to other peoples work. That right there will tell you whether or not people like it. I've noticed two things: people either really like them or they don't like them at all. Yours look good by the way.

Powered by SkinBrowser!
Reply #3 Top
Thanks for the suggestion.

I have 2 skins I'm working on, logons are definitely easier by comparison.
Reply #4 Top
ok.....you said please.................
It is not my intent to be mean spirited, but here you go..........

The wallpaper is by skurvash..............so I have to ask, what did you do, other than set a few colors?
I hope you don't take offense......... you ask for feedback and you're not getting any, which can be very frustrating, so I thought, I'd speak up.....
Reply #5 Top
Thank you and good point.

I have a "Sinister Lantern" logon and wallpaper coming out as soon as it's approved, that wallpaper is my own. I guess it would be better to get feedback on that one since everything is mine.

It is frustrating having no comments on stuff. I almost think my stuff is ugly, so I've learned to ignore what I think. My friends say everything is great, so I can't rely on them. And other people just don't seem to comment. *shrug* So thank you for your comment.
Reply #6 Top
we all have stuff passed up, my newest wallpaper, sucked right when i uploaded it then i updated it to the right version but none really took notice, stuff happens and stuff gets passed up easily.
Reply #7 Top
Jobeleca....if you want fair-dinkum commentary I'd be happy to do it...but via email....public floggings can hurt more than they help...
Reply #8 Top
My email address is in the profile.