Heh, users, potential customers, customers, ex-customers, bah, there couldn't possibly be a relation there! I think the topic at hand, that providers of a free product or service don't like getting demands from a few people who don't have anything constructive to say is blinding to legitimate input from those that do pay or could potentially pay for products and services.
A more recent example of this is experience is the release of AlienGUIse. Although it was released at 'no cost', the developer thought it was some how unfair of me to mention my dissatisfaction on how it was released and some problems I had associated with it. The initial response I received was very corse, but through private channels, as I explained my exact points and the emotion level came down, I'm certain the essence of my complaints were logical and accurate and good came out of it.
Additionally, I don't think anyone, with any sense at all would agree that harassing, abusive, and brash comments are constructive. Those of course should never be given in the first place, though, I can understand how frustration can allow those feelinsg to be conveyed (on both sides of the coin). However, comments in general, even those that don't offer praise, can be learned from, rather than dismissed completely (no matter who they come from).
Just because one has complaints, doesn't necessarily mean they aren't a customer (good customer even, if you want to measure it by how much they spent or how often they shop at your store). There was a comment some ways up there about most negative comments coming from those that aren't even paying customers. That may be true, I wouldn't know, sounds like an opinion to me, but Cygnus makes the point that I manged to dance around: Users ARE your potential customers, and quite arguably, your most valuable resource. Sure, returning customers (through your subscription based services), are good for business, but hell, isolating potential customers doesn't sound good for business. And to let it be known, I'm not posting this to keep the debate going, I wanted to discuss this with you privately, but this is a public matter that I feel needs to be addressed.
Just as each of us have freely expressed ourselves in this particular board and multiple viewpoints have been entertained, the same should hold true when the topic is a product or service provided. I fully understand that my viewpoint isn't widely shared, here atleast, but I think with a less skeptical, less condescending analysis, good can come out of it, if not the process at least. Also, I hope Brad, Jeff, and everyone knows, that I support the community (and have for years), which is why I'm so vocal on these matters.
Cheers! Anyone that wants to continue this with me in private, feel free to contact me:
[email protected]