Bearing Witness

With palms together,

Good Morning Everyone,



When something is so odious or annoying that to be in its presence causes immediate and extreme suffering what are we to do? Examples might be a very bad smell, the sight of something decaying, or messages regarding this endless, pointless war. What are we to do?



Most of us try to get away from its source. I suppose if we stick our heads in the sand most of our sense organs will not be exposed to much of anything. Yet, there we are, none-the-less, our bodies fully exposed.



Some of us try to run away, yet wherever we go, there we are. With us comes the smells, sights, sounds, tastes, and thoughts of suffering. Still others attempt to deny these exist or that they are, indeed, noxious. "What smell?" they might say in a a controlled and steady voice. Meanwhile people all around them are fainting from its effect.



What are we to do?



Zen Buddhists bear witness. We neither run, walk, or slink away. Nor do we put our head in the sand. We do not deny there is suffering or a cause of it. We explore its cause, we see its cause, and we bear witness to it.



If you have ever sat Zazen and had an urge to scratch yourself somewhere without relieving it, you have experienced bearing witness. The experience is very powerful. We do not deny there is a itch to be scratched. We do not move away from it. We do not ignore it. We simply witness it. In the process we witness a myriad of things about ourselves and the itchy place. Sooner or later, in the act of bearing witness to the itch, the itch recedes. It essentially melts away. We have borne witness to ourselves and our suffering and are alive to tell the tale.



We practice this bearing witness in silence or with respectful testimony (as in civil disobedience) and with complete, mindful attention. So, in the presence of something odious, we bear witness to it. We do not deny it, ignore it, run away from it. We witness it and bear it within ourselves. We use ourselves to end the suffering caused by it. In the process, we learn much about ourselves and the nature of odiousness. It becomes impotent.



So, the next time you are in the presence of something odious, open yourself to it. Allow it to enter you. Learn to deal with life and in turn, life learns to deal with you.



Be well.
1,066 views 2 replies
Reply #1 Top
I am curious about one thing, So Daiho. And it doesn't have to do a lot with this article per se.

You make it clear that you are a ZEN buddhist. But it seems to me that Zen is a particular path. Why would you proselytize a particular path when Buddhism's chief fundamental is that no one path is THE path?

My wife, a native Japanese, read something you said one day that turned her off to you. I have searched for it (not very stringently) and as such I have not found it, but I assume she wouldn't make it up. She said that you said in one of your articles that some such thing was the path to enlightenment. The Buddha clearly taught that there was NO one path to enlightenment. I would like to hear what you have to say regarding your continual patronage of the Zen path of Buddhism. There are a lot of us freestylers out here, and we'd like to benefit from whatever wisdom you have to offer, as well, but it's hard to do that when you make yourself sectarian. It makes you seem like a pawn and a puppet of your order. Is that what you want?
Reply #2 Top
Dear Ock,

Thank you for your inquiry. Zen Buddhism, from its perspective, is the original path. The Buddha taught Zen in his later sutras, especially the wisdom Sutras. All religions have their sectarians. I do not say that other paths do not lead to enlightenment, all paths eventually get us all to the same place, and from a Zen POV, that place is where we reside now anyway. I do say, with the Buddhas of all time, that the practice of Zazen is itself practice realization, and that it is, therefore, the most efficient and effective of paths. It is interesting to me that you would see a monk talking about his path as either patronage or proselytizing. I offer my path, I do not expect anyone to take it. Zen, strictly speaking, is clearly not appropriate for everyone. do not think less of those on other paths, even outside of Buddhism. Yet, I do have the vantage point of a practice centered mind sometimes and I think that the clarity derived from such a practice is a benefit to all who practice it.

Please ask your wife to reconsider and examine the whole rather than the parts. My blog speaks for itself: http://360.yahoo.com/buddhist99


Be well.