SOCIALISM NEVER WORKS

In today's colleges and universities they teach how important it is to plan for societies growth. I have read books written by some brilliant people who insist that if we just planned for growth we would have a utopia. I ultimately concluded that planning is socialism.

Anyone who thinks that planning for growth is anything other than an exercise in futility is either a moron or on drugs. Today’s planners meet in little rooms, draw pretty pictures on paper maps, use the prettiest crayons they can find, and--bingo--the city has a plan. Wonder and utopia are supposed to follow, and never again will the city experience traffic congestion or cosmic disharmony. The great plans, drawn by the learned planners, in search of community utopia, have all failed.

When the government draws up a plan, the plan works if the people who own the land agree with the plan. They think they will make money if they follow the plan. If they don’t think they will make money, the land stays vacant. Interestingly enough, even developers don’t decide what will get built, as they are also subject to market forces. Homebuyers and retail customers decide by choosing to visit the business or buy the homes that are built. Nobody builds a home that no one will buy, or starts a business that no one will visit. Customers and homebuyers decide. Not business, not developers, and particularly not government planners.

That is why I laugh whenever I hear the politicians talk about ten year plans. This week in the state I was born and raised, which is California, they had a bill for a ten year road plan. Of course, it takes 23 years to build a freeway, because they plan and plan, and never build. So what was the morons solution? Another plan of course. They have planned so well in California that today the roads are extremely congested, the houses cost entirely too much, the schools are horrendously overcrowded, the budget is out of balance, and they are running short on water, electricity, and gasoline.

And the fools continue to extol the soundness of government plans. We know that socialism is a failed experiment, as demonstrated by the failure of the Soviet Union. The moron politicians, however, think that they are smarter than the Russians and that socialism will work in California if we just have the right plan. Maybe they should try something different, like freedom and free enterprise, the principles that made this country great.
3,602 views 10 replies
Reply #1 Top
hmmmmm you musta overplanned posting this article?

more to the point, you're claiming prop 13 was a socialist plot launched by comrade jarvis? cuz it aint at all difficult to do a lil bit of infrastructural archeology detecting and accurately date when we began to slide downhill into this:

the roads are extremely congested, the houses cost entirely too much, the schools are horrendously overcrowded, the budget is out of balance, and they are running short on water, electricity, and gasoline.


you forgot public libraries and parks being underfunded outta existence.
Reply #2 Top
Hi Marvin, how is life in la-la-land?

I feel obliged to point out that you have repeated your entire article within the text. Why is this?

1) To make it look more comprehensive than it is,
2) Because 'the principles that made this country great' cause brain damage; or
3) Because you didn't do enough planning?

But wait, apparently 'planning is socialism' ...
Reply #3 Top

feel obliged to point out that you have repeated your entire article within the text. Why is this?

I am sorry.  I dont see this.  Is it perhaps your browser?

Reply #4 Top
'I am sorry. I dont see this. Is it perhaps your browser?'
Yes, that may well be the case. Funny that it's not happening with any other blogs I look at though. Marvin's blog has 5 paragraphs initially, but this rises to 9 (a complete duplication, but two paragraphs get concatenated) when I click to show comments. Sorry Marvin.
Reply #5 Top

Yes, that may well be the case. Funny that it's not happening with any other blogs

psst!  It's a conspiracy!

Reply #6 Top
in firefox it is just showing up as the original article, followed by another copy of it in another box. Most likely something lost in how the browsers parse the html of the site's layout. I've seen this happen on other blogs as well.
Reply #7 Top
'in firefox it is just showing up as the original article, followed by another copy of it in another box'
I'm using Firefox, and it's jamming it all into the same box. Maybe it's a different version or something.

'psst! It's a conspiracy!'
Definitely, Dr Guy - Firefox is a product of the free market system, after all! I guess sometimes CAPITALISM doesn't work either!
Reply #8 Top
Does that cause the double boxes? I'd always wondered about them, but just assumed they happened cos I use a mac and hardly anything is fully compatible.
Reply #9 Top
Actually Marvin, in all seriousness, not a bad article.  I dont totally agree, but you did make some good points.
Reply #10 Top
It’s a real stretch say that urban planning is socialism. The problems you cited, such as traffic congestion, result from a LACK of urban planning; there aren’t enough highways to handle the load and they lack a decent mass transportation system. While it may be true to some extent that controlling growth sometimes leads to overpriced housing, mostly it’s just the economic laws of supply and demand. In Portland, Oregon, for example, urban planning has worked fairly well. They don’t have all the ugly urban sprawl like we have here in Denver, and the cost of living in Portland remains less than Denver.